Comparing 16-Hour and 24-Hour Overnight ICU Resident Schedules to Study Effects on Patient Safety, Resident Learning, and Wellbeing
Led by The Hospital for Sick Children · Updated on 2025-04-11
20
Participants Needed
5
Research Sites
52 weeks
Total Duration
AI-Summary
What this Trial Is About
Researchers are investigating the effects of different overnight work schedules for doctors in training residents working in intensive care units ICUs in Canada. The study aims to understand how 16-hour shifts compare to 24-hour shifts in terms of patient safety, resident education, and resident wellbeing. This research addresses concerns about how tired residents might affect patient care, learning, and burnout, with a focus on providing high-quality evidence relevant to Canadian healthcare settings.
The study compares two common ICU resident schedules 16-hour overnight shifts versus 24-hour shifts. Each ICU site will use both schedules for 52 weeks in a randomized order. Residents on the 16-hour schedule work overnight calls without preceding daytime shifts, while those on the 24-hour schedule work an 8-hour day followed by a 16-hour overnight call. Both groups receive formal handover training to support safe patient care. Consent is obtained for resident-specific measurements.
Participants include ICU patients, residents, supervisors, and frontline ICU staff. Researchers will assess patient outcomes such as hospital mortality up to 90 days after ICU admission and adverse events during ICU stays. Resident education will be evaluated through tests of clinical reasoning and procedural skills, while wellbeing will be measured using assessments of burnout, sleepiness, and health ratings. Data collection occurs during residents 4-week ICU rotations, with analyses accounting for differences between ICUs. The studys results aim to guide policies balancing patient safety, resident training, and wellbeing.
CONDITIONS
Brief Title
Intensive Care Unit Resident Scheduling Trial
Research Team
W
Weeda Zabih
J
Jordan Dang
Not the Right Trial for You?
Explore thousands of other clinical trials that might be a better match. Sign up to get personalized trial recommendations delivered to your inbox.
ICUs have sufficient rotating residents from accredited Canadian training programs to provide at least 20 overnight in-house coverage periods in 28 days
ICUs agree to participate in schedule randomization and measurements
Patients admitted to ICU during study periods
Residents enrolled in accredited Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada specialty training programs (excluding critical care medicine)
Residents able to perform overnight in-house duty with supervision
Residents have the first 4 weeks of their ICU rotation entirely in one period
Supervisors include ICU physicians responsible for resident supervision
ICU frontline staff include registered nurses, respiratory therapists, pharmacists, social workers, physiotherapists, and occupational therapists providing ICU care
You will not qualify if you...
ICUs without rotating residents performing overnight in-house duty
ICUs anticipating major staffing changes (e.g., adding or removing intensivists or fellows)
ICUs unwilling to have resident schedules randomized or to provide study measurements
Patients already in ICU at the start of a study period
Residents enrolled in critical care medicine specialty training
Residents unable to perform overnight in-house duty
Residents whose first 4 weeks of ICU rotation are not in one continuous period
Residents with ICU rotations shorter than 4 weeks
Your Study Journey
Screening
Duration - 2 to 4 weeks
Participants are screened for eligibility to participate in the trial.
Participants include ICU residents and patients admitted during study periods meeting eligibility criteria.
Treatment
Duration - Each schedule applied for 52 weeks at each ICU site with crossover between schedules
Participants experience ICU resident duty schedules of either 16-hour or 24-hour overnight shifts during their ICU rotations. Residents also receive formal handover training as part of the study.
Residents have continuous shifts according to assigned schedule during ICU rotations lasting 4 weeks
Follow-up
Duration - Up to 90 days following index ICU admission; assessments during and after 4-week ICU rotations
Patients are observed for outcomes including mortality and adverse events up to 90 days following ICU admission. Resident wellbeing and education outcomes are assessed during and after ICU rotations.
Patient outcomes measured daily during ICU stay; resident assessments occur during 4th week of ICU rotation
How is the study designed?
Study Type
INTERVENTIONAL
Masking
NONE
Allocation
RANDOMIZED
Model
CROSSOVER
Primary Purpose
HEALTH_SERVICES_RESEARCH
Number of Arms
2
Similar Trials
Improving HIV Testing in European Hospitals by Introducing Dedicated HIV Teams A Multicenter Study Across Ten Countries
A Mentalization-Based Program to Improve Well-Being and Mental Health in Children Aged 8 to 11 and Their Families Across Europe
Chemokeyp Feasibility Study to Improve Safety Data Capture for Cancer Patients Receiving Systemic Treatment in Emergency Care
Community-Led Actions to Improve Mental Health, Cardiovascular Health, and Antibiotic Use
Focusing on Reducing Overmedication and Enhancing Health Equity
Through Participatory Research in Elche, Spain
Fit2Play Youth Afterschool Program for Physical Activity and Nutrition Education
Community Park-Based Health Promotion Study for Children Ages 6 to 14
Evaluating Continuous Vital Sign Monitoring Using Wearable Sensors
in a Norwegian Surgical Ward Effects on Patient Outcomes, Safety Culture, and Nursing Staff Experiences
Study of Personalized Binaural Beat and Spatialized Music to Improve Behavioral and Psychological Symptoms of Dementia in Assisted Living Residents
Study of the EviBody App Personalized Digital Support for Healthy Lifestyle and Well-being in Adults
Impact of 2D, 360, and Virtual Reality Videos on Anxiety and Pain in Children and Young Adults Preparing for Medical Procedures
Comparing 16-Hour and 24-Hour Overnight ICU Resident Schedules to Study Effects on Patient Safety, Resident Learning, and Wellbeing