Comparing Permanent and Slowly Absorbable Sutures in Open Shouldice Groin Hernia Repair A Pilot Randomized Trial
Led by Northwestern University · Updated on 2026-10-23
200
Participants Needed
1
Research Sites
N/A
Total Duration
AI-Summary
What This Trial Is About
Researchers are evaluating whether slowly dissolving stitches work as well as permanent stitches for repairing groin inguinal hernias in adults using the Shouldice technique, which does not use mesh. The study aims to find out if dissolving stitches reduce long-term groin discomfort without increasing the chance of the hernia coming back within one year. It also explores differences in complications, pain, quality of life, and foreign body sensation, as well as the feasibility of a larger future study.
Participants will undergo an open Shouldice hernia repair where the type of stitcheither permanent polypropylene Prolene or slowly absorbable polydioxanone PDSis assigned randomly during surgery. The study compares these two methods by closing all four layers with one of the sutures. Participants will not know which stitch they received until one year after surgery or earlier if complications arise.
During the study, participants complete questionnaires about pain, activity, and quality of life before surgery and at 30 days, 6 months, and 1 year afterward. Routine surgeon visits occur at about 30 days and one year post-surgery, with an additional research phone call around 6 months. Researchers also monitor for hernia recurrence, complications, and sensations of foreign material in the groin throughout the year, aiming to collect complete data for most participants.
CONDITIONS
Brief Title
Permanent Versus Slowly Dissolving Stitches for Non-Mesh (Shouldice) Groin Hernia Repair
Research Team
M
Megan Melland-Smith, MD
M
Maria Narvaez Pereyra, MD
Not the Right Trial for You?
Explore thousands of other clinical trials that might be a better match. Sign up to get personalized trial recommendations delivered to your inbox.
This table compares participation in this trial with other options available for this condition. The information is drawn from published research and the trial’s study details and is provided for educational purposes only.
Factors
PDS Suture (Slowly Absorbed)
Prolene Suture (Permanent)
What it is
Slowly absorbable monofilament polydioxanone (PDS) suture used for all four layers in open Shouldice inguinal hernia repair.
Permanent monofilament polypropylene suture used for all four layers in open Shouldice inguinal hernia repair.
Active comparator arm; patients receive permanent suture Shouldice repair.
Primary use
Offers support during healing; suture gradually dissolves, leaving no permanent implant.
Provides durable repair of tissue layers without subsequent suture absorption.
How it is given or performed
Surgeon completes all four tissue layers using slowly absorbable PDS monofilament suture in open Shouldice technique.
Surgeon completes all four tissue layers using permanent Prolene monofilament suture in open Shouldice technique.
Evidence status
The trial is actively recruiting and will provide direct comparative outcome data for PDS versus Prolene. No published outcome data yet for PDS in Shouldice repair.
Published expert consensus and case-control data support Prolene for Shouldice repair, showing low recurrence rates and durable outcomes.
Important limitations
Absorbable sutures could lead to less durable repair if tissue healing is insufficient; long-term comparative outcomes versus permanent suture are not established.
Permanent sutures may cause long-term foreign body sensation or suture-related discomfort in some patients; recurrence rates depend on surgical technique and patient factors.
Disclaimer: This comparison is created with the help of artificial intelligence(AI) and may contain errors or missing information. It is not medical advice and does not mean one option is better or safer than another. Clinical trials are still being studied, and joining a trial is your choice. Please consult your healthcare professional before making any decisions.
Who Can Participate
Age: 18Years +
All Genders
Eligibility Criteria
You may qualify if you...
Male or female patients 18 years or older
Symptomatic unilateral inguinal hernia
Body mass index (BMI) of 30 or less
Ability to provide informed consent
Must speak and understand English
You will not qualify if you...
Urgent or emergent hernia presentations
Contaminated surgical cases
Previous inguinal hernia repairs on the same side as the current hernia
Femoral hernias
Adults unable to consent
Pregnant patients
Bilateral inguinal hernia repairs
Your Study Journey
Screening
Duration - 2 to 4 weeks
Participants are screened for eligibility to participate in the trial.
Surgery and Follow-up
Duration - 12 months
Participants undergo open Shouldice hernia repair with either permanent or slowly dissolving stitches chosen randomly during surgery. They complete questionnaires before surgery and at 30 days, 6 months, and 1 year after surgery. Routine follow-up visits occur about 30 days and 1 year after surgery, with a research phone call around 6 months.
3 in-person visits and 1 phone call
How is the study designed?
Study Type
INTERVENTIONAL
Masking
SINGLE
Allocation
RANDOMIZED
Model
PARALLEL
Primary Purpose
TREATMENT
Number of Arms
2
Similar Trials
Study of Activity Guidelines After Surgery for Single-Sided Inguinal Hernia Repair
Managing Chronic Pelvic, Inguinal, Sacroiliac, and Coccygeal Pain in Adults
Evaluation of Multimodal Therapies and Treatment Outcomes
Comparing Laparoscopic Percutaneous Extraperitoneal Closure and Intracorporeal Suture Techniques for Repairing Inguinal Hernia in Children
Comparing Early Recovery After Conventional and Robot-Assisted Laparoscopic Repair of Bilateral Inguinal Hernia in Adults
Comparing Dexmedetomidine and Dexamethasone with Bupivacaine for Pain Relief in Children Ages 2 to 6 Undergoing Inguinal Hernia Surgery
Evaluating Acupressure Effects on Pain After Laparoscopic Totally Extraperitoneal Inguinal Hernia Repair A Randomized Sham-Controlled Trial
Study of Non-Contact Camera-Based Vital Sign Monitoring
During Surgery Using rPPG Technology
Flemish Registry on Outcomes After Inguinal and Femoral Hernia Surgery
Tracking Pain, Recurrence, and Quality of Life After Repair
Comparing Modified Guarnieri-Desarda and Lichtenstein Techniques for Repairing Inguinal Hernia in Adult Men
Comparing Permanent and Slowly Absorbable Sutures in Open Shouldice Groin Hernia Repair A Pilot Randomized Trial
Have more questions? Get in touch with our team for quick support
Published Research Related To This Trial
Polypropylene vs. stainless-steel wire suture: short-term recurrence rate after shouldice primary inguinal hernia repair, a non-inferior analysis among 1120 patients. A case-control study.
Christoph Paasch, Marguerite Mainprize, Richard Hunger...